advertisement


October 30, 2006

Absolute Sandman, Vol. 1

Absolute Sandman Creators: Neil Gaiman, writer; Sam Kieth, Mike Dringenberg, Chris Bachalo, Michael Zulli, Kelley Jones, Charles Vess, Colleen Doran, Malcolm Jones III and Steve Parkhouse, artists.
DC/Vertigo, oversize hardcover, color, 612 pages, $99

So? One of the reasons comics were so long considered cheap, disposable entertainment is that was the way they were made. The traditional comicbook — a 32-page saddle-stitched newsprint booklet with a glossy cover — came about because it fit the technology of the era that originated the comicbook, i.e. the 1930s.

Hardcover have been growing in popularity in recent years, offering oversize editions with DVD-style extras, but nothing comes close to the insane beauty of DC/Vertigo's release of The Absolute Sandman Vol. 1, a 612-page massive oversize hardcover volume reprinting the first 20 issues of Neil Gaiman's classic and ground-breaking fantasy series.

A recolored panel from Absolute Sandman This volume — the first of four that will collect the entire series — is the comicbook readers' equivalent of watching a pristine, newly restored version of "The Godfather" or "Citizen Kane" from the best seat in the house on the largest screen in town. With 18 of the 20 issues herein recolored and printed on a lovely paper stock that's thick but not too thick; glossy but not too slick, flipping through this book is an irrestible invitation to revisit the dreaming no matter how many times you may have read these stories before. The book also is expertly bound. You can lay it flat on the table without cracking the spine and see the double-page spreads stretch uninterrupted across the gutter.

Content wise, the recolored stories and larger format gives these tales, which were good the first time around though perhaps not as good as later issues, is given new life. To make it truly compelling, there is more than 65 pages of bonus material. Most fascinating is the original proposal for the series that Gaiman wrote in 1987. The proposal's similarity to the series as it came to see print is fascinating and shows just how well-formed the concept was in Gaiman's head before any sketches were drawn. Also excellent is the full script and pencil art for issue 19, the Shakespeare story drawn by Charles Vess that won the World Fantasy Award for best short fiction in 1991. (The rules for the award were changed immediately after this event to prevent another comicbook from winning it again.) This also is new content. Collections of "Dream Country" (#17-20) included Gaiman's full script to issue 17, and DC could easily have just reprinted it again

A recolored panel from Absolute Sandman The price is steep at $99, and while that may be too much for many to afford, it's not an unreasonable price. The cost of the three paperback editions that collect the stories presented in Absolute Sandman Vol. 1 would run about $45 new; the last hardcover editions sold for about $30 a piece.

This is arguably the finest of DC's Absolute editions, which have improved in quality from an already high level to the level of minievents for such recent volumes as Absolute Dark Knight and Absolute Kingdom Come. But Sandman is the state of the art; it's hard to imagine a more lovely volume being published by anyone. Grade: A+

Oct 30, 2006 at 04:06 PM by Tom McLean in Reviews | Permalink

Comments

I've already bought these wonderful stories twice...the original comic books when they were first published and then the collections...but this sounds like a grand edition that I, despite my best Scrooge-like intentions, may not be able to resist (DC's Absolute Editions are too often like catnip for wide-eyed fanboys like yours truly :-)

Nice review.

Posted by: Michael K. Willis at Oct 31, 2006 11:44:11 AM

Give me a break! Most hardcover books of any genre do not cost $99...We live in a country where a majority of companies have deternined all of us are rich and stupid...Collectibles that are over priced make fans like myself draw the line at what we will buy..Oh,yeah..i have all the Sandman comics..and consider them brilliant..Heads up on a trend that is already here..companies make paperbacks smaller and charge more for them...

Posted by: Bruce Joyner at Nov 1, 2006 12:25:31 PM

I don't agree, Bruce. I think it's great that popular stories are available in a number of editions: comic book, trade paperback, hardcover, digest, absolute edition, etc. That way, people have the choice of which edition to buy and how much they want to spend and the book has that many more chances to reach audiences. I'm sure later paperback editions of Sandman will benefit from the re-coloring job done for the absolute editions.

Posted by: Tom McLean at Nov 1, 2006 2:45:50 PM

Tom, I understand what you're saying about having stories available in many formats. I think that's terrific.

But what DC (and other companies who engage in schemes like this) is doing is effectively monetarily punishing early adopters.

Like Bruce, I bought all the individual issues of Sandman. Then I bought all the graphic novels. Now I'm considering buying this Absolute edition.

If this edition was available in the first place, I would have bought that and been done with it. And I would have been very happy.

But DC and companies like it count on us forking out more money for just a bit more content.

And don't assume Absolute Sandman will be the last version of these tales. The trend will be to another edition with, let's say, a variant cover and maybe Neil's autograph. And maybe a rejected Dave McKean cover that's never been seen before.

And guess what? Us fan boys will shuck out that money for that edition and the next, and the next.

Posted by: Dale Cruse at Nov 2, 2006 10:08:49 AM

I can't say that I totally agree with the comments about 'this edition should have been available in the first place.' For one, it completely misses the point that this actually could not have seen print in this format before as print capabilities weren't at the current levels they are today, not to mention the fall in paper prices has allowed for a much larger format and better paper stock to be used.

As far as this being a 'scheme' on DC's part ... Well, nobody is actually holding a gun to consumers' heads saying 'You must buy this'. There has been no talk of previous printings, both in hardcover and softcover, becoming unavailable now that the Absolute edition is out.

As far as 'punishing' early adopters ... Well, part of that is addressed in my point about the printing process, but again there is nothing about the STORY that has been changed. The series hasn't been Lucased in any way shape or form. It's just been cleaned up, modernized tastefully.

I too own several versions of this series. And I loved them all when I bought them. I love this Absolute edition most of all because it feels like the series has finally been given the epic treatment it deserves.

And as far as other versions of this Absolute edition coming out, I suppose I could see that happening ... In maybe (maybe!) another 10, 20, 30 years when we come around to another anniversary. I'm not holding my breath until then.

Yes, the price tag would be steep (although many places have it for significantly less - and I'm Canadian so finding a good deal is even more impressive) if this were a normal printing. Having received my copy today and perused it, I can fully well admit that the price being charged is fully worth it. It's a beautiful packaging of a beautiful story.

Can't wait for the next volumes to release!

Posted by: A.M. Din at Nov 2, 2006 10:21:49 PM

I have just received my copy of Absolute Sandman Vol. 1, and I have to agree, it is THE best packaging I've ever seen for a reprint.
The effort that's been put in to make this publication ultra special is certainly not lost as you take it out of the slipcase. The recoloured artwork looks fantastic and the larger format makes every detail in the panel available to the reader. $99.00 may seem like a lot to pay (over here in the UK it is in some shops for £65.00) but how much would 20 'ordinary' comic issues cost you? The huge leap in quality is worth the extra money - but if you're happy with your older versions then fine.
Absolute Sandman is not an essential purchase just a beautiful one.

Posted by: Peter Johnstone at Nov 17, 2006 2:16:36 AM

If you would let the fan girl speak this time...

I've adored Gaiman's work since my older brother recommended him to me, and I have read his books ever since... though not all. I fell in love with the Absolute Sandman the moment I saw it on display and immediately had it reserved, hoping my father would buy it for me (here in the Philippines, it's worth P4,499, about $90)

I know my brother can understand you guys, and I believe I'm trying to understand it myself too. May it be consumer insight or whatever, any Gaiman work on display will automatically draw me into it. :)

P.S. My dad did buy it for me. Aside from struggling with its weight (which is probably heavier than me), the dreams get better after reading a few pages from it.

Posted by: Jen at Jan 20, 2007 7:33:58 PM

Does anyone have any idea when the second volume is to be released, if, infact it is at all?

Posted by: Jenny at Jan 24, 2007 12:11:55 PM

I believe these are set for annual release, so don't expect Volume 2 until fall 2007.

Posted by: Tom McLean at Jan 24, 2007 12:23:34 PM

Post a comment






TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/4113/6592172

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Absolute Sandman, Vol. 1: