advertisement


March 28, 2008

Review: Ghost Whisperer #1-2

Gw2 Creators: Becca Smith and Carrie Smith, writers; Elena Casagrande, artist
IDW, 32 pages, color, $3.99 each
So? The CBS series this comic is based on has been a quiet but consistent marketing innovator, having taken the show to Comic-Con the past couple of years and having previously produced a promo graphic novel. (I'm not sure why these efforts haven't paid off more in winning over the kind of vocal and visible fans that keep "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" alive — is Jennifer Love Hewitt's portrayal of psychic Melinda Gordon too feminine and not hip enough for that crowd? I don't really know.) This five-issue outing written by a pair  scribes Smith and Smith show a good grasp on what works in comics, with the each issue's done-in-one mystery tying in quite well to a longer arc involving a larger threat to Melinda that's a bit more fantastic than what the TV show usually pulls off. There's a bit of repetition in that both mysteries revolve around the deaths of pick-on teenage girls whose spirits want revenge, but the clean art, moody colors and solid scripting make this an easy and enjoyable read. Grade: B+

Mar 28, 2008 at 02:26 PM by Tom McLean in Reviews | Permalink

Comments

Well Ghost Whisperer doesn't have a hipster writer who has her talk in pop references, nor does she beat up vampires twice her size. Hence her non-appeal among "Buffy" fans.

Posted by: Alan at Apr 3, 2008 5:01:45 AM

Post a comment






TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/4113/27557446

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Review: Ghost Whisperer #1-2: