Time to motor through the giant stack of books that has been piling up throughout the summer and see what we think.
The Alcoholic (Vertigo, $19.99, out
in September) is a groovy tale that’s the best so far of Vertigo’s new
series of original graphic novels. Novelist Jonathan Ames manages to
bring his distinctive voice to comics with a script that’s funny,
touching and seemingly tailor made for artist Dean Haspiel. I still
think $19.99 for 136 black and white pages is a bit much — even in
hardcover — but this is a cool tale that goes down easily enough to be
worth it. Grade: A-. ...
Tales of the Starlight Drive-In
(Image Comics, $19.99) is a convincingly bittersweet love letter to the
passion pits that once dotted the American landscape. Newspaper
reporter Michael San Giacomo writes a series of short vignettes that
cover the history of the Starlight Drive-In from its glory days to the
present, with different artists illustrating each story. The stories
have a ring of authenticity and it’s easy to imagine San Giacomo — a
reporter for the Cleveland Plain Dealer — might have
dug up these stories while rummaging through the paper’s library of old
issues. The final comics are by nature a bit uneven, given the number
of artists involved, but this still ends up an effective and satisfying
taste of nostalgia and Americana. Grade: B. ...
Janes in Love (DC/Minx, $9.99, out in September), the sequel to last year’s debut Minx title, The Plain Janes,
is thankfully more of the same — an appealing story about normal,
creative girls trying to fit in. Reuniting writer Cecil Castellucci and
artist Jim Rugg, the Janes are more charming, earnest and fun than
ever, making up for a plot that falls shorter on the drama. Some of
that likely comes from the novelty having worn off a bit, but it seems
unlikely to slow down the Janes, who already are set to appear in a
third book. Grade: B.
Todd McFarlane’s Spawn is still motoring along quite nicely in issues #178-180 (Image Comics,
$2.95 each), proving that it’s still possible that superhero comics can
succeed as entertainment all on their own. Writer David Hine has had a
good run on this title, playing with the basics of Spawn in fun ways
while never forgetting this is essentially a horror comic. The art also
is slick and fun. Brian Haberlin serves up some excellent horror work
while Mike Mayhew delivers some stunning photorealism in #179’s
standalone tale of a WWI veteran who has to choose eternal death to
save the life of his bastard son. These comics won’t change anyone’s
life, but they were a lot of fun to read. Grade: B+. …
I received a copy of Jonny Gambit 01: The Prodigal Son Preview Edition (Pure Comics)
in the mail and it’s like an artifact from the black-and-white boom of
the 1980s. That may be appropriate, given that the character previously
appeared in a single issue about 20 years ago. The story and the art
are a pure throwback to that time — though not in a completely
unpleasant way. The story about a futuristic city gone wrong and the
racing toughs who may be able to save the man who can fix it is pure
1980s, complete with an elaborate and complete backstory. The art holds
this back a bit — it’s flat, angular and simple and would benefit
greatly from some quality inking and the addition of color. Grade: C.
Color is no problem for Radical Comics, whose books are all lushly painted and tell stories thick with blood and oil. Hercules: The Thracian War #1-4
($2.99 each) seems like it wants to tap into the ancient war action of
"300" and "Beowulf," but comes off more like "Conan." I’m not sure why
Hercules and his coterie of demi-gods aren’t using their “powers” more,
but an even stranger note is struck by the extent of the characters’
thirst for blood. The dialog is full of references to eating hearts,
scooping out brains and cannibalism, eventually making it hard to see
the heroism in the patriotically-motivated Hercules’ and his crew. Grade: B-. …
Caliber: First Canon of Justice #1-4
($2.99 each) has a little more depth to it, but suffers from the lack
of clarity that has often plagued comics that are fully painted by
anyone save perhaps Alex Ross. Characters are so fully integrated into
their realistic surroundings that it’s often hard to tell who’s who
from panel to panel. That’s made even tougher by a script that revels
in taut dialog over any kind of direct exposition that could clear up
the plot and perhaps inject some deeper personalities into this Western
take on the legend of King Arthur that John Woo is attached to direct. Grade: C. … Radical’s third series, Freedom Formula #1
($2.99), is a sci-fi tale that evokes anime in general and “Akira” in
particular. The story — optioned by Bryan Singer as a film for him to
produce — is standard fare about futuristic couriers who take their
duties to clients and their families very seriously, but what this is
really all about is the cool Transformers-style tech and a futuristic
setting artists Chester Ocampo and Kai depict with scope and
imagination. Grade: B-.
DC/Vertigo continues to roll new ongoing series with a pair that go back to the imprint’s roots in fantasy. Madame Xanadu #1
($2.99) has been out for a while, revamping an old DCU character with a
new origin from writer Matt Wagner and artist Amy Reeder Hadley. This
features lots of the fairies, magicians and medieval-style witchcraft
in a style that evokes at least a little bit the classic “Midsummer
Night’s Dream” issue of Sandman. The book looks
lovely and reads well, though it’s underwhelming enough to raise
questions about why this character would be revived using the approach
the least likely to win over the superhero fans who are most likely to
know her. Grade: C. …
Also out for a while now is House of Mystery #1
($2.99), a more traditional Vertigo book, featuring oddball fantasy
tales from strange characters. The stories are quirky and creepy in a
fun way — no surprise, given that this is written by Jack of Fables
collaborators Matthew Sturges and Bill Willingham — and there’s enough
variety here to lure the curious back for more. Grade: B.
The Damned: Prodigal Sons #1 (Oni Press,
$3.50) is a solid comic that improves greatly on the first book in this
demons-as-the-mob series. Writer Cullen Bunn and artist Brian Hurtt
draw their characters and the boundaries of their fictional world well.
Hurtt in particular brings care and craft to the art, which all by
itself lifts this above the vast majority of today’s indie comics. Grade: B+ ...
Resurrection #1-4
(Oni Press, $3.50) has an interesting concept, a top-notch writer in
Marc Guggenheim of ABC-TV’s “Brothers and Sisters,” and plenty of rave
reviews. I agree that the basic idea is a good one — What happens after
the aliens who invaded in “War of the Worlds” or “V” head home? But
four issues into the series, not much has happened save long
conversations that appear borrowed from other movies. In some ways,
this is too much like a TV show and not enough like a comic. It doesn’t
help that the art by David Dumeer, while decent, at times doesn’t well
match the dramatic content of the writing. More action and less talk
would help this a lot. Grade: C.
Recent Comments