In an age of so much conspicuous certainty, there's something to be said for a documentary that inspires powerful feelings of ambivalence. So it is with "Outrage," which was previously reviewed by Variety (and discussed by my colleague Ted Johnson on his "Wilshire & Washington" blog) at the Tribeca Film Festival but premieres Oct. 5 on HBO.
Written and directed by Kirby Dick, "Outrage" made news by naming names of Republican politicians and operatives who are closeted gays, many of whom have inveighed or voted against gay rights. There is, of course, a clear element of hypocrisy in this, but I'd still stop short of activist Michael Rogers' contention that these figures represent "traitors to their people" who must be exposed. However offensive their hypocrisy might be, there's something troubling about using outing as a form of political retaliation against those who don't adhere to the gay-rights platform.
As "Outrage" demonstrates (the subtitle is "Do Ask. Do Tell"), the GOP has also cynically used gay-bashing as a political tool, which makes the participation of gays in those efforts particularly galling. In addition, prominent Republican officials have seen their careers stall because of whispering campaigns about their sexuality, usually hiding behind code words about them being "too moderate."
Still, the forced collision of private and public lives is distasteful, and one suspects an already-debased political climate won't exactly be elevated by spending even more time obsessing over who politicians are screwing in the literal sense -- whether that's "family values" senators on the right, or Bill Clinton and John Edwards on the left. Nor it it clear, as activists maintain throughout the film, that mainstream news outlets -- faced as they are with dwindling resources -- are somehow abdicating their journalistic responsibility by failing to go sniffing around politicians' closets.
For all that, "Outrage" talks to all the right people and Dick methodically builds his case, beginning with Sen. Larry Craig's arrest in a Minneapolis bathroom and concluding with a 30-year-old clip of the late Harvey Milk, in which he argues that coming out is a vital step on the road to gay rights and equality.
Even if you don't agree with the tactics, "Outrage" deserves to be seen, discussed and debated. Bigotry against gays -- much of it rooted in religion, but also predicated in part on obvious political calculus -- is ugly; the pertinent question is whether that justifies outing as a response.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On a separate gay-progress front, the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamationissued a somewhat misleading annual scorecard on representations of the lesbian-gay-bisexual-transgender community for the 2009-10 TV season, under the heading "Where We Are on TV." The detailed report can be found on GLAAD's website.
"Misleading" because the focus is strictly limited to scripted programming, which conspicuously omits the heightened presence of gays in primetime thanks to reality TV. Hell, half of Bravo is seemingly devoted to gay characters, albeit in the unscripted realm.
In addition, simple numerical counts aren't always completely illustrative of the bigger picture -- namely, the quality of the characterizations. Those include some promising additions this season, from the gay couple on ABC's "Modern Family" to the teen dealing with coming out to his peers and family on Fox's "Glee." How those programs will unfold remains to be seen.
As is, the study finds slight increases in LGBT characters among series regulars overall, accounting for 3% of characters on the broadcast networks. Depictions on cable declined -- again, based solely on scripted fare, though that reduced presence appears to be accounted for almost entirely by the departure of Showtime's "The L Word."
Recent Comments