"Lost": Episode 9, "The Shape of Things to Come"
As usual, Sawyer cuts through the haze and gives voice to one of the key questions that viewers have had about "Lost" for a long time now.
For sure, "Lost's" stormy, sensational return with No. 9 of this season, "The Shape of Things to Come," written by Brian K. Vaughan and Drew Goddard and helmed by Jack Bender, was one hell of a Big Ben episode, a tour de force for thesp Michael Emerson.
But it was also a big night for Sawyer, who demonstrated the kind of courage and resolve under fire that only those with the highest moral character, integrity and compassion possess. First he does a "Saving Private Ryan" and risks all to save Claire as the invasion begins. Then he tries to do the same for Hurley, only Hurley won't let him. Sawyer, we always knew you had it in ya.
"Lost" scribes surely did give us a lot to process in tonight's return after the five-week, strike-hangover hiatus. Let's review the apparent tangibles before we dive into the 'what the #$%^&?' issues.
**We now know that by Oct. 24, 2005, Ben makes his way to Tunisia.
**We know that Ben kept up with news coverage of the early days of the Iraq war, more than a year before Oceanic flight 815 crashed. Shock and awe, indeed.
**We know that Sayid reconnects with his beloved Nadia after he gets off the island, no doubt because of his notoriety from being one of the Oceanic 6. And we know that Nadia is killed in L.A., three blocks away from the intersection of La Brea and Santa Monica. Don't tell me they were having lunch at the Formosa Cafe? Pink's? Shopping at Target?
**We know that Ben was lying in the episode before to Locke about not knowing what the smoke monster really is. It sure looked like he summoned it toward the end to fend off the invaders. I don't believe we've ever gotten quite as good a look at Smokey as we did in this seg.
**We know, or were told, that Hurley is now an important key to connecting with Jacob. He "knows where the cabin is," Ben sez more than once (I think?) in this seg. Friday afternoon update: After chewing on this, I'm starting to think that Jacob is something that comes to different people at different times, and people see different things in Jacob and the cabin. Kind of like the essense of spiritual belief. It's about the believer, not the deity.
**We know that Jack and Kate, et al, now know beyond a shadow of a doubt that the landing party has evil intentions. Faraday told them as much. I'm starting to want to strangle him by that skinny tie of his. And I still can't stand Rebecca.
**We know that Charles Widmore drinks Scotch. We know that Ben and Charles Widmore have met before and have been at each other's throats for a long, long time.
**We know that ABC severely tried our patience in the first half-hour with three commercial breaks less than 10 minutes apart. They seemed to be a little bit better in the second half-hour, but please, Alphabet gurus, have mercy with all the breaks.
Now for the most perplexing parts, mythologically speaking:
**What's up with the doctor -- the Mitch Pileggi look-alike -- turning up on the shore with his throat cut?
**"He changed the rules" -- Ben sez in his shock after the Widmore boat captain bad guy from Widmore's boat, Martin Keamy, kills Alex. He sez it again at the end when he's confronting Widmore in his hotel suite and vowing to kill Penelope. "I'm going to make you wish you hadn't changed the rules." Friday afternoon update: I'm not smart enough to have grasped this after one viewing last night, but the theories I've read on line make a lot of sense. We know that the time-travel business is rooted in certain rules, i.e. Star Trek's prime directive. Me thinks Ben had seen a future in which Alex was alive, which was why he went through the bluff with Keamy, because according to the "rules," Alex had to live.
**Ben singles out Hurley as the key to finding Jacob's cabin again. But as the invasion of New Otherton begins, he also tells Locke "it's very important that you survive."
**Sayid says "Benjamin, it was an accident" in the flashforward in Tikrit after Sayid kills the supposed hitman and Ben convinces Sayid that there's a fishy connection to the island and Nadia's death. What's an accident? The murder of the hitman, or is Sayid settling some other score? When last we saw Sayid and Desmond on the boat in the seg "Meet Kevin Johnson," he was so disgusted with Michael for going to work for Ben that he turned "Kevin" into Keamy as an agent of Ben's.
**"I know who you are and what you are," Widmore tells Ben in their confrontation. "Everything you have you took from me." And a few seconds later Widmore further needles him: "That island's mine. It always was and it will be again." Oh, do tell...Friday afternoon update: And as for Ben saying "you know I can't kill you" to Widmore, I believe that it again harkens to the idea that time travelers can't change the future. Perhaps Widmore has to live, at least in the moment of that bedroom confrontation, so that Ben can prevail in the future. Another theory has it that Ben and Widmore are each other's constants. Which is very provocative.
Of course there was so much more to ponder. And there was plenty of fun observational stuff.
I could be wrong but it seemed like this was the first time we'd seen Vincent in a long time, in the opening scene when Bernard finds the doctor washing ashore. Dog's beautiful and blond as ever.
Loved seeing Locke, Sawyer and Hurley playing Risk, with Hurley bouncing Aaron on his knee. Brought back memories of many an afternoon spent strategizing on how to protect the Eastern theater. Loved Hurley's line about "Australia's the key to the whole game," which seemed fraught with import. It also dawned on me just then that of our core castaway ensemble, Claire is the only one who's actually from Oz.
The first flashforward scene of Ben landing in the Sahara desert -- with a parka on, no less -- made me think of "Lawrence of Arabia," don't ask me why. Friday afternoon update: Can't believe I missed the symbolism of Ben landing with a thud in the Sahara desert. Time travel, duh! And can't believe I didn't see that his parka had the name of Halliwax on it.
Found it interesting that Locke hesitated to act but Hurley did not during the attack when Sawyer was running around with Claire in his arms looking for an open door. Got a kick out of the fact that after all the shooting and explosives lobbed into New Otherton, Miles rang the doorbell of the house when Ben, Locke, Sawyer and Hurley were bunkered in to deliver the walkie-talkie.
Loved the use of "A Day in the Life"-esque dramatic chord in that scene, just before Ben learns that Alex is the hostage.
After Locke and Sawyer put their guns down and decide not to shoot each other, Sawyer shows his true feelings about Hurley. "If you harm one hair on his curly head...so help me God I'll kill you," he tells Locke.
And finally, in the sparring between Widmore and Ben at the end, there's no better way to move us along than plain and simple language Widmore uses to taunt the master psycho-emotional manipulator.
"The hunt is on," Widmore assures Ben.






Cynthia Littleton is deputy editor, news development at Variety and a veteran television reporter.
Subscribe to this blog's feed

Well we knew that somebody would die on this episode many people thought it would Claire but it was Alex. So the smoke Monster is control by Ben in the secret room. Sawyer saved the day and Claire. Ben is a person that is trying take what Widmore has long control. I think that Ben is in way over his head on this one.
Posted by: Joe | April 25, 2008 at 08:43 AM
Agreed. Great to have Lost back. One Extreme TV Moment (those moments where-yes, I know it's a TV show, but...) Sawyer is being shot at by a handful of ex-military, who have picked off, with single accurate shots, a handful of island residents BUT a wooden picnic table and knee high white picket fence is no match for their automatic machine gun fire?? Thought I was watching an old ep of GI Joe for a moment.
On with it. Highly doubting Widmore's man killed Nadia- if Ben is telling Sayid so and all he has is a traffic picture, which could have been anywhere in the world, as proof, my eyebrow goes up. Could it be that Sayid has nothing left now to stop his rampage against the people that tried to cover up the crash and exterminate the island? That Nadia's death was the "accident" Sayid is talking about?
There were the remnants of a polar bear that we saw Rebecca dig up in Tunisia as well- now a polar bear and a parka. That would be a hell of a hatch.
Ben and Widmore- sounds like it's been a long elaborate game of chess until Widmore changes the rules. The pawns can go but the don't mess with the core players or family.
Posted by: BigTex | April 25, 2008 at 08:56 AM
Keamy isnt the boat captain.
Posted by: krayzeman | April 25, 2008 at 09:30 AM
Do the Losties have massive amnesia? Ben is a sociopathic mass murderer, who spews nothing but lies every time he opens his mouth. So why, when he says "they're going to kill you," does everybody drop everything and believe him? The whole series is now resting on the conceit that everybody believes everything a compulsive liar and murderer says. I couldn't stand it anymore, and turned the episode off half-way.
Posted by: Me | April 25, 2008 at 09:31 AM
I don't want to seem rude, but, please learn the correct names of the characters before writing about the show. This article appears to be written by a 14 year old who just starting watching the show and has absolutely no understanding of the plot. Do you think that using "sez" is cute ? It's horrifying to know that you get paid to write this poorly.
Posted by: tyrone | April 25, 2008 at 03:44 PM
Thanks for your recap! I thought it was a fantastic episode, and would probably rank it as the second best of the season so far!
Also, I'm not so sure that Ben is time travelling, exactly. Remember that there's a displacement in time with the Island and the outside world. Since Daniel Faraday has made his debut on the series, Lost has seemed to be suggesting that the Island is in a "time bubble." Meaning present day Island time may be late 2004/early 2005 but non-Island time can be late 2005.
Also, I think it's a safe assumption that Ben landing in the Tunisian Sahara answers the question of why there are polar bear remains in the Tunisian Sahara. Maybe there's a portal from the Arctic to Tunisia, and other portals throughout the world.
That would give us an idea about the logistics of Tom leaving the Island to recruit Michael and to be back in time to be shot by Sawyer.
So not necessarily time traveling in the sense that most are taking it. I think of it more like what they did on the show "Sliders," just in the same universe and areas of existence.
Posted by: Phil | April 25, 2008 at 07:39 PM
Didn't it seem odd that when the bad guy Martin was holding the gun to Alex's head that nobody in the house with Ben - all armed to the teeth - threatened to shoot Martin?
Posted by: Doug | April 27, 2008 at 05:26 PM
Wow, I was thinking the same thing. Although I was more horrified by the fact that so many of the readers have to correct you on a regular basis. I don't understand how someone who writes a tv blog comes off sounding like they just started watching LOST.
Posted by: Us | April 29, 2008 at 04:10 PM
It seems fishy, but remember that if Keamy were to die, there are at least five other freighter assault people and at least one sniper with their sights set on Alex and anyone who may be in the House they've taken cover in. We also know they have a rocket launcher, but it's unlikely and ghastly to think that they would have used that to snipe Alex!
Also to the commenter directly above me, who is this "us?" I see only one person complaining, and that is counting the two posts that are apparently from the same person.
If you don't like what's being written, shoo off and don't read it. Next.
Posted by: Phil | April 29, 2008 at 10:10 PM