"Lost": "There's No Place Like Home," Parts 2 and 3
"Lie to them. If you do it half as well as you do it to yourself, they'll believe you."
Oh Locke. Jeremy. Locke. Bentham. Whatever your name is. Wherever you are...
"Lost's" fourth season finale, "There's No Place Like Home, Parts 2 and 3," wasn't 88 minutes of television. It was somewhere between a religious experience and a psychedelic journey through time and space, through the earth's crust, past the frozen donkey wheels, past disappearing islands, heroic dudes making the ultimate sacrifices for the ones they love and a latenight break-in at a low-rent funeral parlor in a bad part of L.A. I am still tingling from the enormity and the emotional gamut of the experience.
Friday ayem update: Ratings are in. Big but not nearly as big as you'd think for two of the Greatest Hours of Television Ever. No doubt the DVR numbers will add significantly to the viewership by next week, and the web streams off ABC.com will surely be flowing during the next few weeks. 9-10 p.m. hour of finale averaged 11.9 million viewers and 4.6 rating/13 share in adults 18-49. 10-11 p.m. hour did 12.5 million and 5.1/14 in 18-49.
There's so much to think about, so much info to process and plot development to parse that it would be folly to try to offer anything like a definitive commentary on these segs while the first viewing is still reverberating around my brain. I didn't know how they were going to be able to top last season's gut-wrenching finale, but Carlton Cuse and Damon Lindelof (who penned both hours) and helmer Jack Bender surely did.
So first some top-of-mind observations and a few questions. After repeat viewing(s), I'll try to draw some larger conclusions. There's plenty of time. I think part of the emotional roller-coaster of tonight is having to come to grips with the fact that we won't get any new episodes until January-February. Shudder.
**A moment of mega-significance seems to be the scene toward the end in the life boat (I felt the ghost of Tallulah Bankhead in the scene) when Hurley is talking about "miracles" and Locke moving the island. "One minute it was there, the next minute it was gone." Hurley's statement was such an echo of the conversation Jack had with Locke in the fantastic, fantastic, beautifully shot scene in the Orchard station greenhouse where those two are once again going at it on the science/faith seesaw.
"Just wait til you see what I'm about to do," Locke warns him, and then tells him he has to lie about the
survivors' plane crash experience to protect those left behind. Now fast-forward toward the scene in the life boat and Jack as always is scoffing at the notion of miracles, but, the minute he steps into what turns out to be Penny's boat (Penny's boat!), what's the first thing he cooks up? The Big Lie, for their own protection. For his own protection, as Locke warned him in the greenhouse: "the knowledge (Jack has) will eat you alive from the inside out. You're going to have to lie." Oh boy.
**Even by this show's standards, this finale was packed with action -- once again, fantastically photographed and edited with such originality. No action-movie, fight-sequence cliches. This episode literally kept us on the edge of our seat, gasping and screaming. The big fight early on between Sayid, Kate, Keamy, Richard and the Others was impossible to follow -- just like such a chaotic scene would be. I couldn't tell who was shooting at who at any given point. Even Keamy's death at the hands of a raving Ben was unnerving for its sudden jolt of rage from a man who's already certifiably psychotic. I gotta believe Keamy is really dead this time (the boat did go boom after all) but with a body that big you just never know...
**Locke may be well on his way to prophet-eering, but he still has a heart. "Ben, you just killed everyone on that boat." "So?" is Ben's response. Turns out Variety's Justin Kroll was right on target two weeks ago when he deduced that the thing strapped to Keamy's Montana-sized forearm was a heart rate monitor that could detonate a bomb.
**Walt! Wild to see him visiting Hurley in the mental hospital, traveling across the country with his grandmother to do so. He's still got those probing eyes, even if he is less gawky. "We're lying because it's the only way to protect everyone who didn't come back," Hurley explains -- lucidly, I think.
**Miles, Charlotte and Faraday -- I can't even pretend to get those three. I still wonder if there's a Miles-Edgar Hallowax (or whatever his name is) connection. Can't help it. And I guess now we know Charlotte has been to the island before. Or at least she's been to the island where it was before...right?
**Sawyer pulls the Charlie card of selfless sacrifice. He did it so well. I think I know what he whispered in Kate's ear just before jumping out of the plane -- must've been some info about his darling Clementine. Which might explain the errand that Kate ran on his behalf months (years?) later when she's back in L.A.
And why that errand pisses off Jack so much -- no one is supposed to know that Sawyer didn't die right away in the crash.
**An addition to the great lines in "Lost" history from Hurley: "Dude, I've been having regular conversations with dead people. The last thing I need now is paranoia." This delivered to Sayid after he makes a visit to the Santa Rosa mental hospital, kills the bad guy who's parked outside the hospital and informs Hurley that he's being watched. Hurley's right: More conspiracies is the last thing he needs. Love Sayid's blow-dried look in these later flash-forwards.
**Incredible is the only way to describe Yunjin Kim's perf in the helicopter scene where Sun leaves Jin and
then watches the freighter blow up. Utterly terrifying, utterly devastating. I can't help it -- even though I saw the fireball, I'm holding out hope that Jin somehow makes it. Sun is also really good and icy in the later scene where she confronts Widmore. "We're not the only ones that left the island," she snaps at him. Interesting implication there, eh?
**"You can go now." Not the words you want to hear from Christian Shephard, head of non-corporeal communications for Jacob Ltd. But that's what he says to Michael. I'm not holding out much hope that Michael survived the big boom, despite what Hurley indicated to Walt in the mental hospital scene.
**"They will follow your every word," Ben tells Locke of Richard and the faithful Others, who are in fact waiting for Locke on the island while Ben's busy thawing out the donkey wheel. This is so strange. "Welcome home," Richard, he of the permanent eyeliner, says to Locke. Creepy, but not quite as creepy as Ben telling Locke: "Sorry I made your life miserable."
**The white light, the piercing tone when Ben finally turns the wheel. It's got to be meant to meant to evoke Hiroshima, no? Or at least the imagery of what a nuclear blast looks like that we've become accustomed to in movies and artists representations of Hiroshima.
**Claire! Good gravy she looked spooky in her fleeting appearance at Aaron's bedside. "Don't you dare bring him back," she instructs Kate.
**See you in another life, brother..." Doesn't need any explanation. Oh Des. Somehow, I'm thinking that Des and Penny, happy as they are to be reunited, are going to have a hard time living with their part in the Big Lie. And they don't even know, at least not yet, about Ben swearing his vengeance against her father by killing her.
**And the casket goes to ... Locke. Safe to say that was the LAST PERSON ON EARTH that I expected to see in that pine box. (BTW, anybody know the speed-metal tune Jack was listening to in his car as he pulled up at the Hoffs Drawler funeral parlor? Reader Dashiell reports it was "Gouge Away" by the Pixies. Not exactly speed metal...) How much information was shoveled at us in that last mind-boggling scene? Bad things happened on the island after Jack and Co. left. Locke, who's now known inexplicably as Jeremy Bentham (a historical figure who was an 18th-century English philosopher, economist and social reformer who was influenced by ... John Locke), has apparently been haunting Kate and Jack and urging them to get the gang back together for an island visit. With Ben apparently set to be their tour guide.
With all this rattling around my brain, how can I possibly be expected to sleep tonight? And how can we possibly wait nine months!







Variety's Team TV -- Cynthia Littleton, Stu Levine, Jon Weisman, Andrew Wallenstein and A.J. Marechal -- provides a roundup of stories big and small, as well as opinions and analysis from across the TV dial.
Subscribe to this blog's feed
A tremendous episode. Now, this is what great television is all about. Everything else on the telly pales in comparison. Yes, it will be a very, very long time till next winter. I already anticipating the grieving process when the show comes to an end in two more seasons. I sincerely hope it doesn't wrap everything up neatly. I figure a few unanswered mysteries might lead to "Lost: Revisted". I agree that watching Sun in the helicopter agonize over the exploding ship with her husband left behind was terrifying to watch. I hope some Emmys will be awarded for this episode.
Posted by: Jeff in Chicago | May 31, 2008 at 05:24 PM
Never did Locke are whatever his name is!he got what he deserve.Then we see Claire telling Kate not to bring Aaron back so is Claire alive are dead.Yunjim Kim gave the best performance of the show as Sun when she sees Jin die.
Posted by: Joe | May 31, 2008 at 03:26 PM
Interesting Note: Jeremy Bentham is still around, despite being dead for 176 years. As part of his will, his body was preserved and still shows up for meetings, listed as "present but not voting".
Which likely means: Locke is not done yet.
Posted by: Kevin | May 31, 2008 at 02:48 PM
The thing with the Nielsen ratings for Lost is that something around 30 percent of the audience are stream, download and DVR viewers so the Live+7's should be much larger, more around the 15 million range. It's still down year to year, but that's the case with every show on ABC since they returned from hiatus.
Boston Legal was down considerably when it returned to its original timeslot (though, that may have a lot to do with not having the DWtS Results Show as a lead-in), Grey's Anatomy and Ugly Betty were down about three million from last year's finale numbers, and the network's Ace, DWtS was down year to year as well.
24, being a heavily serialized drama like Lost, Experiences precisely this kind of viewership trend.
Regardless of the year to year losses, the finale numbers were great, and without a doubt anyone who saw the finale will be making a point to return when 5 begins in '09. And hopefully All shows can recover their live viewership in the Fall.
Posted by: Phil | May 30, 2008 at 05:32 PM
Interesting how Ben blew a hole in the wall of the Orchid chamber but he/someone has obviously done that trick before. It seems to me that "moving the island" would be moving it through time, yes? I did have issue with Kearny- why wouldn't Ben, with all his pent-up rage against him, really make sure he was dead after Richard shoots him? And Walt visits Hurley, and then? A cross country trek for... hopefully we find out. Tell you what, if I were Sawyer, I would have swam up to the beach in my underwear, if that much clothing- do you know how much pants weigh when wet let alone swimming back to the island?
Nevertheless, a very enjoyable 2 hours of television to say the least. Hurts so good how puzzle pieces come together at the same rate new questions arise.
Posted by: BigTex | May 30, 2008 at 09:55 AM
Cynthia, the song in Jack's car was the classic Gouge Away by the Pixies.
Posted by: Dashiell | May 30, 2008 at 05:24 AM
Oh yeah, and now that we know that Locke is dead in 2008 (!!!), Who is the new leader of the others?!
And, could Locke have tipped off Sun about Ben being the one who killed Keamy and vicariously being responsible for the freighter going "boom" with Jin possibly still on it?
How will this affect Ben's convincing her to go back with the rest of the sixers (and the body of Locke)?
And if the Oceanic 6 has to return to the Island, what about Faraday, Jin (I continue to refuse to believe that he's dead. there's still hope!), Frank and Desmond?
I pray that no more cast members get stopped by the Hawaii 5-0!
Posted by: Phil | May 30, 2008 at 03:24 AM
I'm still reeling from everything that happened in that shocking, jaw dropping, tear inducing season finale!
I'm still in shock after what happened to Michael and Jin, though I have at least a little bit of hope for Jin...
First, wtf happened to Faraday? He was on the zodiac with some of the peripheral losties, initially trying to get to the freighter, but I don't think ever actually made it nor did he make it back to the Island before it zipped off to God (and the EP's) knows where.
I'm praying that he was far enough from the Island to have not been transported so he can look for any possible survivors among the sinking freighter... like maybe Jin who managed to jump overboard or was launched overboard during the blast.
And it looks like Sun has the same thirst for vengeance that Ben has. I wonder if she'll get to Ben before Ben gets to Penny?
And Sawyer swimming to shore with Juliet watching on, I think it's safe to say that was the moment that she forgot about Jack.
I also like this little consortium that Ben is pulling together. I wonder how he'll be able to convince Kate and Sun to go along with his plan to get the band back together.
I wonder if the flash forwards will be resuming next season.
Posted by: Phil | May 30, 2008 at 02:25 AM
Great review! I loved this episode.
Did you see they found some reverse speech in the phone call Kate got?
http://losteastereggs.blogspot.com/2008/05/reversed-phone-message-for-kate.html
Cant wait till season 5!!!!!
Posted by: marie | May 30, 2008 at 01:40 AM