No, Kotaku, GameRepublic was not making a Tom and Jerry Game
I haven't been spending my holidays doing much kotaku reading, but when a friend send me this post, I really wasn't sure whether to laugh or cry. Michael McWhertor at Kotaku read this long, slightly crazy interview with GameRepublic head Yoshiki Okamoto and came up with the following nugget o'news, which was apparently hidden so carefully that 1Up, the site that conducted and posted the interview, didn't even realize it was noteworthy:
The evidence? Deep in the middle of the interview (conducted before Brash went under) comes this exchange:
1UP: You're working on a movie-based game for Brash Entertainment. Even if you can't say what license that is right now, how is the project coming? How hard is it to work on a movie license? You haven't done that kind of project before, have you?
YO: Actually, we're working on a Tom and Jerry movie/game tie-in [laughs]. Yeah, when Brash is ready, we'll both announce the game together. But technically, this isn't my first movie licensed project.
Hopefully I don't need to explain to Cut Scene readers the many contextual hints that make it obvious Okamoto wasn't being serious. Even beyond this exchange, though, it was a totally tongue-in-cheek interview during which Okamoto gave 1UP Editor James Mielke marital advice, complained about how women don't dig him, and said, "I used to have a girlfriend that I was riding too. But I went out to the parking lot to get her the other day and she wasn't there anymore."
And of course there's just common sense. Brash picked up a few crappy licenses in its day, but Tom and Jerry? Which, by the way, is not a movie. And then assign it to a fairly well regarded developer like GameRepublic? That should strike most knowledgeable readers as a bit suspicious. And probably merit more reporting. Like a Google search.
Which would have turned up that I have previously reported the movie license GameRepublic was actually developing for Brash was "Clash of the Titans." Many other sites have since picked that up (like this IGN listing), so I'm not just assuming everyone has to read this blog.
So, ummm, yea. There's nothing wrong with quickly linking to all the interesting videogame news on the 'Net. That's what sites like Kotaku do best. But sometimes a little more diligence may be in order.
[This post slightly edited by me a few hours after posting when I realized it was a bit too snippy]





Subscribe to this blog's feed

Yes,your article is very good.I like it.Thanks for your sharing. Spending your days complaining about insteadof covering movie/game news is not journalism either.
Posted by: Omega Replicas | August 29, 2009 at 02:02 AM
I always heard something from my neighbor that he sometimes goes to the internet bar to play the game which will use him some gw gold,he usually can win a lot of GuildWars Gold,then he let his friends all have some Guild Wars Gold,his friends thank him very much for introducing them the GuildWars money,they usually cheap gw gold together.
Posted by: cheap gw gold | March 11, 2009 at 09:30 PM
I'm not sure this warrants an entire blog post. All the same - that's some crack investigative journalism on your part - you're a regular Bob Woodward.
Posted by: Peter | December 29, 2008 at 01:31 PM
This entry, and others like it, are exactly what I enjoy most about this blog. Take it easy on the pretentious ramblings of the "symposium". That stuff is a guilty pleasure.
Posted by: DJ | December 29, 2008 at 07:07 AM
I did cut those "alternate titles" upon re-consideration. But in fairness to Frank's point, I think amongst all the "major" videogame bloggers, I am pretty good about not focusing too much on videogame journalism inside baseball stuff. I agree that doing too much of that is often highly annoying. Instead of complaining, just do good work, right? I try to adhere to that. I mean geez, I haven't even commented once on the grand videogame writers' symposium going on over at Shawn Elliott's blog.
And I have to disagree with Joe's assertion that I run "one of the snidest, most self-important game blogs on the web." I think I run THE MOST self-important game blog on the web, actually.
-Ben Fritz
Posted by: Variety.com * | December 28, 2008 at 09:12 PM
Why should he NOT call out Kotaku, or any other frequently trafficked news site, for posting misinformation? I consider it a public service to stop the spread of misinformation.
Posted by: G-Man | December 28, 2008 at 08:09 PM
"Alternate title 2: Reading one line from a long interview conducted by someone else is not journalism"
Spending your days (as you seem to be doing more and more often lately) complaining about "games journalism" instead of covering movie/game news is not journalism either.
Posted by: Frank | December 28, 2008 at 05:37 PM
Ironic post coming from one of the snidest, most self-important game blogs on the web...
Posted by: Joe | December 28, 2008 at 02:11 PM