It took some Web scouring, but here's the White Stripes' set list from their Gotham show, courtesy themodernage.org. (PS, we loved it).

When I Hear My Name/ Dead Leaves/ Icky Thump/ Cannon/ John the Revelator/ My Doorbell/ I’m Slowly Turning Into You/ Jolene (cut short)/ Hotel Yorba/ I Think I Smell a Rat/ Effect and Cause/ Apple Blossom/ Same Boy You’ve Always Known/ Catch Hell Blues/ St. James Infirmary Blues/ Cold, Cold Night/ I Want to be the Boy to Warm Your Mother’s Heart/ You’ve Got Her In Your Pocket/ [Guitar solo]/ Astro/ Union Forever (with some lyrics to Little Cream Soda thrown in)/ Blackjack Davy/ Black Math