Variety.com
variety.com
Home  |   |  Text size: a- A+
    Log In    Variety Discussions    Glossary
  • News

    • Latest
    • Film
    • TV
    • International
    • Business
    • Music
    • Legit
    • Technology
    • Home Entertainment
    • Video Games
    • Weekly Variety
    • News By Topic
    • RSS News Feeds
  • Reviews

    • Film
    • TV
    • Legit
    • Music
    • DVD
    • Video Game
    • Book
    • Album
    • All Reviews
    • RSS Reviews Feeds
  • Charts

    • Domestic Film Box Office
    • Foreign Film Box Office
    • Legit Box Office
    • Film Production
    • TV Production
    • Primetime schedule for 2008-2009
    • Game Trailers Rankings
    • Eligible Broadway Venues
    • Festival & Market Submissions
    • Facts on Pacts
    • Slanguage Dictionary
    • All Charts
  • Features

    • 'Mamma Mia!' 10th Anniversary
    • Greenberg Glusker 50th Anniversary
    • 'ER' Series Finale
    • 'Rachael Ray' 500 Episodes
    • ShoWest
    • How to shoot a film in France
    • Mip 2009
    • Pyramedia 10th Anniversary
    • Singapore: HD Hub
    • Education Impact Report '09
  • People

    • Births
    • Exec Shuffle
    • Hitched
    • Tenpercenteries
    • Obituaries
    • Players
  • Profiles

    • Movies
    • TV Shows
    • Video Games
    • Distributors
    • Networks
    • Production Companies
    • Studios
  • Media Careers

    • Search Jobs
    • Get Job Alerts
    • Post a Job
  • Blogs

    • BLTv
    • H.A.L.
    • Littleton on the Air
    • Peter Bart
    • The Cut Scene
    • Technotainment
    • Thompson on Hollywood
    • TV Season Pass
    • Wilshire and Washington
    • Army Archerd
    • Columns >
    • Timothy M. Gray
    • Peter Bart
    • Brian Lowry
    • Todd McCarthy
  • Video

    • Movie Trailers
    • Variety Reviews
    • TV Clips
    • Dailies News
    • Music
    • Variety Screening Series
    • Sundance Film Festival
    • Video Game Trailers
    • All Video
  • Photos

    • Film Festivals
    • Premieres
    • Theater
    • Award Shows
    • Emmy Photos
    • Screening Series
    • Ten To Watch
    • Tribute/Obituary
    • Video Games
    • Recent Galleries

« Wolfgang's Vault Open For Downloads | Main | Bob Dylan Set List Analysis »

June
4
Adding Transparency To A Critical Process: Giving Chicago Its Proper Place In The Rock 'n' Roll Canon

Chicagoalbumart Chicago and the Doobie Brothers perform two shows this week at the Gibson Amphitheatre, yet another summer tour double bill that has made Chicago one of the strongest B.O. attractions at amphitheaters over the last several years.
Previous years have featured Earth, Wind & Fire, America and Huey Lewis & the News, but this year's trek will bring Chicago fans in contact with a set of fans who have something in common: An feeling that their band is being unfairly snubbed by the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
Well one side is right, despite there being a number of striking parallels. Both acts came of age in the early 1970s playing distinctive music that had only a modicum of a link to a 1960s sound; both had minor hits with covers, Chicago doing Spencer Davis Group's "I'm a Man" and the Doobies with the Byrds' "Jesus is Just All Right"; they had success using different vocalists; and their signature sound at the end of the decade bore little resemblance to the sound they started with. At various times in the 1970s, they were among the five most popular bands in the U.S.
The Doobies, out of San Jose in Northern California, delivered magical harmonies and a blueprint for rock music that drew on a range of elements; few acts fused hard rock and boogie with a front porch sensibility so convincingly; you can't tell me that the Dave Matthews Band does not rely on a similar formula.
Chicago, on the other hand, were revolutionaries. "CTA," "Chicago," "III," "V," "VI" and "XI" pushed the limits on conceptual boundaries and displayed superb musicianship. And they had hits, which has somehow been labeled as a sin over time.

Doobie Any kid who studied an instrument in the early 1970s saw the songs of Chicago  and the Doobie Brothers as worthy challenges that once commanded, were sources of pride Both had exceptional, gifted guitarists though Chicago's Terry Kath has never received his true due while Jeff Baxter's talent have been thoroughly examined. The horn section and the key songwriter, Robert Lamm, still lead Chicago, which can still impress in concert when they step away from the wall of hits and proffer their more adventurous music; the Doobies less so.
Endurance does not win prizes in the performing arts -- until the creators are beyond retirement age. Chicago could have called it quits after Kath's death and let their 10 or so studio albums be the entirety of their catalog or they could have imploded in the early 1980s when MTV started shaping pop music and examples of '70s excess were tossed aside. They not only soldiered on, they reinvented their sound, creating a new mainstream sound for adults. Not my cup of tea musically, but an achievement nonetheless.
Rhino Records will release on June 17, "Stone of Sisyphus (XXXII)," the album Chicago turned in to Warner Bros. in 1993 that the label refused to release. Produced by Peter Wolf, it was a return to the adventurousness of their early '70s output and was deemed not commercial enough. The guys in the band packed their things and left WB at that point, but have never seen fit to release this work.Chicagotheband
I was a fan of the band between the ages of 11 and 16 - basically the classic "Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is?"  through "Wishing You Were Here" - and was hired to write liner notes for their boxed set and few reissues in 2003. It feels far enough removed that I can return to writing about the band critically, which I have begged off for the last several years. Material on the boxed set, by the way, emphasized their deft compositional abilities, specifically the manner in which they used 20th century classical technique.
In the years since   I wrote those liner notes - and I went in thinking the band had been under-appreciated critically and deserving of the Hall of Fame - I have been appalled by the acts that have made it in ahead of them. It shows the bias of the hall's voters - they are either too old t have the wistful childhood memories of the early '70s or too young to fully appreciate how distinctive they were in the pop landscape at the time. Chicago made a difference back then.
Having taken in mostly theater since returning from Cannes ("Chorus Line," "Jersey Boys"), my one concert was Cher, leaving me with 69 concerts and 181 acts to go on the path to 100/300. At least summer is here.

Posted at 04:31 PM in Year in A Critical Life | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfc7553ef00e552c302158834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Adding Transparency To A Critical Process: Giving Chicago Its Proper Place In The Rock 'n' Roll Canon :

Comments

"Chicago, on the other hand, were revolutionaries."

You're kidding, right?

I'm not saying the Dave Clark Five was a good idea, but Chicago? I'd got for ELO before them.

Posted by: G. Sassoverde | June 06, 2008 at 09:44 AM

Well said! I agree with you on all points. As all serious Chicago fans know, Chicago DESERVES to be the Hall of Fame.

I flew in from Portland, OR for the Chicago/Doobies show in Phoenix on June 3 and I can say both bands are in fine rockin' form and a good time was had by all...Anyone who's a fan of either of these bands should not miss this tour!

Posted by: Melinda Miller | June 06, 2008 at 12:31 PM

Great commentary. If anyone doesn't believe that Chicago weren't revolutionaries they weren't paying attention to music in the late 60's through the mid 70's. Nobody else was doing what they were doing and they were one of the largest grossing acts during that period. Like them or not, they should be Rock and Roll Hall of Fame members.

Posted by: Bob W. | June 11, 2008 at 10:07 AM

Just because you happen to personally be ignorant about Chicago's very LONG career, does not make them ineligible for the Hall of Fame.

Posted by: Mark | June 12, 2008 at 12:31 PM

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

You are currently signed in as (nobody). Sign Out


About

The Set List is written and compiled by Variety associate editor Phil Gallo. Gallo, based in Los Angeles, writes about the music business for Daily Variety and reviews concerts, television shows and theater.

Subscribe to this blog's feed
-- Advertisement --


Featured Post

BEST ROCK RADIO STATION SILENCED
Indie 103.1 goes off the air after demonstrating how variety can define an excellent station.

Archives

  • February 2009
  • January 2009
  • December 2008
  • November 2008
  • October 2008
  • September 2008
  • August 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • May 2008

More...

Categories

  • 50 Years/100 Songs
  • Abe Vigoda
  • AC/DC
  • Adam Green
  • Adele
  • Ads
  • Against Me!
  • Al Green
  • Alan Vega
  • Alicia Keys
  • Allman Brothers Band
  • Alvin Youngblood Hart
  • Amadou & Mariam
  • Amazon
  • American Idol
  • Americana
  • Amy Winehouse
  • Andrew Bird
  • Angie Stone
  • Animal Collective
  • Annie Lennox
  • Anniversary
  • Antony and the Johnsons
  • Apples in Stereo
  • Arctic Monkeys
  • Area 51
  • Aretha Franklin
  • Art
  • ASCAP
  • Auctions
  • Auditions
  • Avril Lavigne
  • Awards
  • B-52's
  • B.B. King
  • Babyface
  • Barack Obama
  • Barbra Streisand
  • Barenaked Ladies
  • Barry Manilow
  • Baseball
  • Beach Boys
  • Beastie Boys
  • Beatles
  • Beck
  • Benefit
  • Best Fwends
  • BET
  • Bette Midler
  • Betty Buckley
  • Beyonce
  • Billy Joel
  • Bisop Allen
  • Black Crowes
  • Black Eyed Peas
  • Black Flag
  • Black Mountain
  • Blake Lewis
  • Blogs
  • Bluegrass
  • Blues
  • Bo Diddley
  • Bob Dylan
  • Bob Marley
  • Bob Mould
  • Bob Odenkirk
  • Bob Weir
  • Bon Jovi
  • Booker T. & the MG's
  • Books
  • Bootlegs
  • Boris
  • Boy George
  • Boz Scaggs
  • Brandi Carlile
  • Brett Dennen
  • Brian Wilson
  • Britney Spears
  • Broadway
  • Broken Social Scene
  • Bromst
  • Bruce Springsteen
  • Busts
  • Butch Walker
  • Byrds
  • Cafe Carlyle
  • Cafe Tacuba
  • Calexico
  • Canceled
  • Carrie Underwood
  • Cat Power
  • CBGB
  • Cedric the Entertainer
  • Celebration
  • Celine Dion
  • Charley Patton
  • Charts
  • Cheating
  • Cher
  • Chick Corea
  • Chris Brown
  • Christmas
  • Circle Jerks
  • Classical
  • Clay Aiken
  • Clive Davis
  • Clubs
  • CMJ
  • Coachella
  • Coldplay
  • Comedy
  • Concert Tapes
  • Concerts
  • Contests
  • Corbin Bleu
  • Counting Crows
  • Country
  • Covers
  • Critics
  • CSNY
  • Culture
  • Culture Club
  • Cure
  • Dan Deacon
  • Dan Deacon Bromst
  • Dance music
  • Dangermouse
  • Dap-Kings
  • Daryl Hall
  • Dave Alvin
  • Dave Stewart
  • David Bowie
  • David Byrne
  • David Vandervelde
  • Deals
  • Dean Martin
  • Death Row
  • Death Row Records
  • Depeche Mode
  • Devendra Banhart
  • DeVotchKa
  • Dexter Romweber
  • Dino Saluzzi
  • Disco
  • Disney
  • DIY
  • Dizzy Gillespie
  • Django Reinhardt
  • Documentary
  • Dolly Parton
  • Donita Sparks
  • Downloads
  • Dr Dre
  • Dr Dre Detox
  • Dr. John
  • Duets
  • Dusty Springfield
  • DVD
  • Eagles
  • Elmore James
  • Elton John
  • Elvis Costello
  • Elvis Presley
  • EMI
  • Endangered Species
  • Eno
  • Eric Clapton
  • Esa-Pekka Salonen
  • Everlast
  • Experimental
  • F Yeah Fest
  • Fads
  • Fall Out Boy_
  • Fantasia
  • Fats Domino
  • Feist
  • Festivals
  • Film
  • Flava Flav
  • Flavor Flav
  • Flight of the Conchords
  • Foo Fighters
  • Food and Drink
  • Football
  • Frank Sinatra
  • Frankie Valli
  • Franz Ferdinand
  • Franz Ferdinand Katherine Kiss Me
  • Franz Ferdinand Madden
  • Gamble & Huff
  • Garth Brooks
  • Gene Clark
  • George Clinton
  • Gilberto Gil
  • Girl Talk
  • Giveaways
  • Glass Candy
  • Glastonbury
  • Glen Campbell
  • Gnarls Barkley
  • Government
  • Grammys
  • Grateful Dead
  • Greg Gillis
  • Guitar Hero
  • Guns N' Roses
  • Gustavo Dudamel
  • Hall & Oates
  • Hank Williams
  • Hank Williams Jr.
  • Hardcore
  • Health
  • Heart
  • Hellogoodbye
  • Henry Cow
  • Henry Grimes
  • Herbie Hancock
  • High Places
  • High School Musical
  • hip hop
  • Hires and Fires
  • Hold Steady
  • Holidays
  • Hollywood Bowl
  • Hootie & the Blowfish
  • Hotel Cafe
  • Husker Du
  • Ice-T
  • In Court
  • In My Room
  • In Rehearsal
  • Industry
  • Instruments
  • Interpol
  • Interview
  • INXS
  • iTunes
  • Jackson Browne
  • James Blunt
  • James Mercer
  • James Taylor
  • Jane Siberry
  • Jane's Addiction
  • Janet Jackson
  • Jay-Z
  • Jazz
  • JD Souther
  • Jeff Garlin
  • Jennifer Lopez
  • Jerry Lee Lewis
  • Jets
  • Jim Bianco
  • Jimi Hendrix
  • Joe Jackson
  • Joe Strummer
  • Joe Zawinul
  • John Brannon
  • John Coltrane
  • John Fogerty
  • John Legend
  • John Lennon
  • John Mellencamp
  • John Pizzarelli
  • Johnny Cash
  • Jonah Ray
  • Jonas Brothers
  • Joni Mitchell
  • Jose Gonzalez
  • Josh Fadem
  • Journey
  • Judy Garland
  • Juno
  • Justice
  • Justin Timberlake
  • Kanye West
  • Karma Chamaeleon
  • Kelly Clarkson
  • Kevin Drew
  • Kevin Shields
  • Kid Rock
  • Kimya Dawson
  • Klaxons
  • Kraftwerk
  • Kurt Elling
  • Largo
  • Lawsuits
  • Led Zeppelin
  • Leonard Cohen
  • Liam Finn
  • Liars
  • Lil Wayne
  • List
  • Little Feat
  • Live Albums
  • Live Nation
  • Lollapalooza
  • Los Angeles
  • Los Lobos
  • Lost
  • Lou Reed
  • Louis Armstrong
  • Lucinda Williams
  • Lyle Lovett
  • Lynard Skynard
  • Madden 09
  • Madonna
  • Mariah Carey
  • Mariza
  • Maroon 5
  • Matt Dwyer
  • Max Roach
  • MC5
  • McCoy Tyner
  • Mercury Prize
  • Merle Haggard
  • Metallica
  • Michael Jackson
  • Michael Roth
  • Mick Jagger
  • Mike Watt
  • Miles Davis
  • Miley Cyrus
  • Moby
  • Mogwai
  • Moody Blues
  • Morrissey
  • MTV
  • Music
  • Musical instruments
  • My Bloody Valentine
  • My Morning Jacket
  • MySpace
  • NAACP
  • Naked Brothers
  • Nas
  • Negative Approach
  • Neil Diamond
  • Neil Young
  • Nels Cline
  • Neville Brothers
  • New jobs
  • New Releases
  • New Year's Eve
  • New York
  • Nick Lowe
  • Nickelback
  • Nils Lofgren
  • Nina Simone
  • No Age
  • Noel Gallagher
  • Nokia Theater
  • Notorious B.I.G.
  • NRBQ
  • Nurse With Wound
  • Oasis
  • Obituary
  • On Sale
  • Oops
  • Opera
  • Ornette Coleman
  • Oscars
  • Otis Redding
  • P Diddy
  • Paint It Black
  • Pat Metheny
  • Patriots
  • Paul Anka
  • Paul McCartney
  • Paul Potts
  • Paul Weller
  • Paul Westerberg
  • Pavement
  • Pearl Jam
  • Pete Seeger
  • Pete Townshend
  • Peter Gabriel
  • Phil Roy
  • Philadelphia
  • Pink Floyd
  • Pitchfork
  • PJ Harvey
  • Politics
  • Poll
  • Portishead
  • Postponement
  • Primal Scream
  • Prince
  • Public Enemy
  • Publications
  • Punk
  • Punk Rock
  • Queen
  • Quoted
  • R&B
  • R.E.M.
  • Radio
  • Radiohead
  • Radiohead In Rainbows
  • Raekwon
  • Ramblin' Jack Elliott
  • Ramones
  • Randy Jackson
  • Randy Newman
  • Ray Charles
  • Ray Davies
  • Records
  • Reissues
  • Remixed
  • Research
  • Reunions
  • Reviews
  • RIAA
  • Richard Hell
  • Richard Thompson
  • Richie Havens
  • Ringtones
  • Roast
  • Robbie Williams
  • Robert Fripp
  • Robert Wyatt
  • Rock and Roll Hall of Fame
  • Rock Star
  • RockFour
  • Rolling Stones
  • Roxy
  • Roy Orbison
  • Rufus Wainwright
  • Rumors
  • Ry Cooder
  • Ryan Adams
  • Ryan Bingham
  • Sales
  • Sam Cooke
  • Sara Bareilles
  • Say Anything
  • Scavenger Hunt
  • Scott Kempner
  • Scotty Moore
  • Seal
  • Sean Carlson
  • Sean Combs
  • Sean Penn
  • Set lists
  • Sex Pistols
  • Shelby Lynne
  • Sigur Ros
  • Silver Jews
  • Siouxsie
  • Sirius
  • Slash
  • Slipknot
  • Smashing Pumpkins
  • Snoop Dogg
  • Sondre Lerche
  • Songs
  • Sonic Youth
  • Soul
  • SoundScan
  • Soundtrack
  • Spain
  • Spice Girls
  • Spiritualized
  • Sports
  • Stanley Clarke
  • Starbucks
  • Stars
  • Status Quo
  • Stax
  • Steely Dan
  • Stephen King
  • Steve Winwood
  • Stevie Ray Vaughan
  • Stevie Wonder
  • Sub Pop
  • Sugar
  • Suicide
  • Sun Ra
  • Super Bowl
  • Suzanne Vega
  • SXSW
  • T Bone Burnett
  • Talking Heads
  • Technology
  • Television
  • Tha Carter III
  • The Clash
  • The Doors
  • The Eagles
  • The Game
  • The Mae Shi
  • The Melvins
  • The Moldy Peaches
  • The Runaways
  • The Rutles
  • The Shins
  • The Stooges
  • The Who
  • Theater
  • Thelonious Monk
  • Theories
  • Thievery Corporation
  • Thom Yorke
  • Ticketmaster
  • Tim McGraw
  • Timbaland
  • Tina Turner
  • Tom Jones
  • Tom Petty
  • Tom Verlaine
  • Tom Waits
  • Tour
  • Trash Talk
  • Tribute
  • Tupac
  • Tupac Shakur
  • Tweens
  • Ty Taylor
  • U2
  • Universal Music
  • Unkle
  • Ute Lemper
  • Vampire Weekend
  • Van Halen
  • Van Hunt
  • Van Morrison
  • Video
  • Video Game
  • Vinyl
  • Wal-Mart
  • Warner Music
  • Warren Zevon
  • Waterboys
  • Weather Report
  • Webcasts
  • Weird Al
  • wendy Wasserstein
  • Wham City
  • Whitney Houston
  • Wilco
  • will.i.am
  • Willie Nelson
  • Wine and Food
  • World Series
  • Wu Tang Clan
  • Wynton Marsalis
  • XM
  • XM Radio
  • Yankee Stadium
  • Yaz
  • Year in A Critical Life
  • Yes
  • Yo La Tengo
  • Zappa

Recent Posts

  • So long, farewell, auf Wiedersehen, good night
  • Rock 'n' Roll For Art's Sake
  • Quincy Jones's New Protege: A Pianist From Cuba
  • Set List: Prince, Hollywood 2009
  • Eddie Van Halen Designs a Guitar to Get Closer to the Fans
  • Review: Leonard Cohen Takes Manhattan
  • Rallying for the Ring: LA Opera Unveils its Take on Wagner
  • Henry Rollins Returns to Radio
  • Review: Jon Hassell, Dhafer Youssef
  • Grammy Awards Press Room First Timer Speaks Truth ... But Has a Bit to Learn

Recent Comments

Variety's Blogs

  • Army Archerd
  • BFDealmemo
  • BLTv
  • Cynthia Littleton: On The Air
  • Peter Bart
  • Technotainment
  • The Cut Scene
  • Thompson On Hollywood
  • TV Season Pass
  • Wilshire & Washington
-- Advertisement --

© Copyright 2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc.
Privacy Policy  |  Terms & Conditions  |  About Us  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Site Map  |  Help  |  Login
    Media & Publishing:
  • Variety   | 
  • Variety Japan   | 
  • LA 411   | 
  • New York 411   | 
  • Video Business   | 
  • ContentAgenda   | 
  • Broadcasting & Cable   | 
  • Multichannel News   | 
  • Publishers Weekly   | 
  • Library Journal   | 
  • School Library Journal   | 
  • Críticas   | 
  • Tradeshow Week

    Manufacturing:
  • Design News   | 
  • Control Engineering   | 
  • Plant Engineering   | 
  • Purchasing   | 
  • Purchasing Data   | 
  • Logistics Management   | 
  • Industrial Distribution   | 
  • Supply Chain Management Review   | 
  • Modern Materials Handling   | 
  • Manufacturing Business Technology   | 
  • Kellysearch

    Subscriptions:
  • All Magazine and eNewsletter Subscriptions
    Business & Printing:
  • DM2-DecisionMaker   | 
  • Zibb   | 
  • Packaging Digest   | 
  • Graphics Arts Monthly   | 
  • Graphics Arts Blue Book   | 
  • Converting   | 
  • Expert Business Source   | 
  • HotFrog USA   | 
  • The Industry Measure

    Gifts & Furnishings:
  • Furniture Today   | 
  • Home Textiles Today   | 
  • Home Accents Today   | 
  • Casual Living   | 
  • Kids Today   | 
  • Gifts & Decorative Accessories   | 
  • Playthings   | 
  • Jlrs, Circ, Keystone

    Hospitality:
  • Hotels   | 
  • Restaurants & Institutions   | 
  • Chain Leader   | 
  • Foodservice Equipment & Supplies
    Electronics:
  • EDN   | 
  • Twice   | 
  • Electronic News   | 
  • Electronic Business   | 
  • Test & Measurement World   | 
  • Semiconductor International   | 
  • Instat

    Building & Construction:
  • Buildcore   | 
  • Building Design & Construction   | 
  • Building Team Forecast   | 
  • Construction Equipment   | 
  • Consulting Specifying Engineer   | 
  • Custom Builder   | 
  • Daily Commercial News   | 
  • Housing Giants   | 
  • HousingZone   | 
  • Interior Design   | 
  • Journal of Commerce   | 
  • Professional Builder   | 
  • Professional Remodeler   | 
  • Reed Connect   | 
  • Reed Construction Bulletin   | 
  • Reed Construction Data   | 
  • Reed First Source   | 
  • RS Means