August
1
Open Letter to John Mellencamp Fans: Listen, Please
After attending numerous John Mellencamp concerts over the last 21 years, one thing i can never get over - and am astonished at how it continues to this day - is his audience's reticence toward new material. It's not the active "head for the bathroom or beer line" during the new material that occurs at his shows, but a new song seems to be a signal for people to start talking about the last tune played or their drive to the theater or how the seats are uncomfortable.
I remember a show he did at the Forum in '91 or '92 at which he attempted to unveil a new, acoustic song. He had to stop after losing his place, I swear because the volume of the chatter had reached a point at which it was drowning him out.
It has been chronicled that few performers face the dilemma Mellencamp faces - his politics don't jibe with the bulk of the audience and he wants to keep moving forward as a writer while they want nostalgia. He delivers the oldies regardless of how well they are aging, which plays a part in why Mellencamp sits squarely in the middle on a scale that has Billy Joel at one end and Bruce Springsteen at other when it comes to making each night a significant for fans in a particular city.
Mellencamp's latest album is full of ballads played in stark sonic atmospheres. Not one of the dozen hits he played Thursday at the Greek Theater shares a tempo or a harmony with the material, and the lyrics are largely an affecting discourse on unsteady relationships and pending death. (Talk about authority winning).
Kudos to Mellencamp for getting four of the songs into the set and surrounding himself with interesting visuals. But too many of fans fail him, choosing instead to yuk it up and holler and act like they're at a ballgame. Too many are trying to be 16 forever and not enough are heeding his latest words: "Nothing lasts forever/and your best efforts don't always pay/Sometimes you get sick/and you don't get better/that's when life is short/even in the longest days."








Subscribe to this blog's feed